There is a question that doesn’t get asked very often about Judas Iscariot: Did he repent?
Most of us have assumed the answer is no, that he died impenitent, swallowed whole by his own treachery. But Matthew’s gospel stops us short of that comfortable conclusion. After the deed was done and the money paid, Judas “felt remorse” (Matthew 27:3, NASB), went back to the chief priests and elders, and said plainly: “I have sinned by betraying innocent blood.” He confessed. He named his sin. He acknowledged the innocence of the Man he had handed over. He even gave back the 30 pieces of silver.
By nearly any standard we apply to repentance, Judas checked the boxes.
And yet.
We don’t believe Judas was forgiven. The Bible doesn’t suggest it. Jesus Himself, who prayed for His executioners from the cross, called Judas “the son of perdition” (John 17:12). Something went profoundly, fatally wrong. Not in what Judas said, but in where he said it.
To understand what that means, we need to walk across a thousand years of biblical history and stand for a moment with another man who sinned beyond what most of us can imagine.
A King, a Rooftop, and a Sin That Shook Heaven
David’s sin is not easy to look at directly. We tend to soften it in the retelling. A moment of weakness, a king who fell. But the full account in 2 Samuel is darker than that. He saw Bathsheba from the palace roof and sent for her, used his royal power to take what wasn’t his, and when consequences threatened his reputation, had her husband Uriah – a loyal soldier and a good man – strategically placed where the battle would kill him. Then he brought Bathsheba into his house as though nothing had happened.
Adultery. (Possibly worse.) And calculated murder.
For nearly a year, David lived with this. The baby was born. The palace staff knew or suspected. David said nothing. He was the king; who was going to confront him?
Enter Nathan.
Nathan the prophet came and told the king a story about a rich man who stole a poor man’s only lamb. And David, in his moral blindness, burned with indignation at the fictional villain. “That man deserves to die!” And Nathan said the words that have echoed through Scripture ever since: “You are the man.”
What happened next is the hinge point of this entire story. David could have had Nathan removed. He could have denied it, deflected it, or buried it deeper. He was the most powerful man in Israel.
Instead, he said six words: “I have sinned against the LORD.”
And then he wrote a psalm.
Psalm 51 and the Direction of Guilt
Psalm 51 is one of the most remarkable documents in human history, a king’s raw, unguarded confession, recorded for every generation to read. David doesn’t negotiate with God. He doesn’t explain the pressure he was under or catalog Bathsheba’s beauty as mitigation. He simply runs toward the only One who can actually do anything about his sin.
“Against You, and You only, have I sinned and done what is evil in Your sight.” (Psalm 51:4)
That line has always puzzled readers. What about Uriah? What about Bathsheba? What about the kingdom David had corrupted with his example? David wasn’t denying the harm done to human beings. He was saying something theologically precise: the only court that can actually adjudicate this guilt, the only tribunal with the authority to forgive or condemn, is God’s. He had sinned against people, but he had sinned against God, and it was to God he had to go.
David ran toward God with his guilt. That is the whole secret.
The Wrong Court
Judas ran the other direction.
After his confession, he went to the chief priests and elders, the very men who had paid him to betray Jesus. He threw the silver at their feet and waited, perhaps for some word of absolution, some human verdict that might quiet the roaring in his chest.
He got nothing useful. “What is that to us? See to that yourself.” (Matthew 27:4)
And so, with that door slammed in his face, Judas rendered his own verdict. He became his own judge, passed his own sentence, and carried it out. When the only Judge who could have actually freed him was still within reach.
This is the tragedy, not merely that Judas sinned, but that he took his sin everywhere except the one place it could have been addressed. He went to the religious establishment. When that failed, he went to self-destruction. He never once, as far as Scripture records, looked up.
And here is where the story reaches across twenty centuries to touch us directly.
We live in an age that offers a hundred courts for our guilt. There are therapists and twelve-step programs, social media confessions designed to perform contrition for an audience, self-punishment dressed up as discipline, and the simple animal comfort of just staying busy enough that the voice inside goes quiet. None of these are without their place. But none of them have the authority to do what only God can do.
Judas’ mistake was not that he failed to express remorse; he did. It was not that he failed to confess; he did that too. His mistake was that he took his confession to people who had no power to forgive him. And when they couldn’t help, he concluded that nothing could.
What God Did With the Darkness
There is one more dimension to this story, and it is a strange and humbling one.
David’s sin, for all its blackness, produced consequences that were eventually redeemed. His family suffered; his sons walked in his footsteps and worse. And yet out of that shattered household, God brought Solomon, a man of such extraordinary wisdom and gifting that his reign became a golden age in Israel’s history. God hates sin, but He is always able to bring something good out of it.
Judas’ betrayal is one of God’s wonders. His sin was not merely redeemed in its aftermath. It was, in the mystery of God’s sovereign will, the very mechanism by which salvation came to the world. The betrayal was load-bearing; the Cross could not have happened without it. And yet no serious theologian concludes from this that Judas is excused, or that his condemnation was somehow unjust.
This is perhaps the most sobering truth the two stories share: God’s sovereignty over your sin is not the same thing as God’s acceptance of your soul. He can weave treachery into redemption and still hold the traitor accountable. The fact that He can bring good from your worst moment does not mean you have come to terms with Him about it.
David came to terms with Him. Judas did not. That is the difference.
Lift Up Your Head
Jesus said that, in the days before His return, the world will be full of people whose hearts are “failing them for fear” (Luke 21:26). And then He said this: “Now when these things begin to happen, look up and lift up your heads, because your redemption draws near.” (Luke 21:28)
Lifting your head is a posture. It is the opposite of Judas walking away, with eyes cast down, toward a rope. It is the direction of David’s prayer in Psalm 51, the face turned upward, toward the only court that matters, the only Judge who is also a Savior.
He is coming again, not this time to bear sin, but to bring salvation to those who are waiting for Him (Hebrews 9:28). That waiting is only joyful if you have first done what David did: brought your guilt to the right place, to the right Person, and received what no priest or crowd or act of self-punishment could ever give. Forgiveness.
So if, like Judas, you’re burdened with a load of guilt, take it to the only court that can set you free. But be aware that: 1) God can only remove your guilt by putting it on Jesus. (See my blog, Highway to Heaven, if you’re not a Christian.) 2) Even after God forgives you and removes every speck of your guilt, He may not remove the consequences of your sin. (Check out the life of David after he sinned to see how his sons broke his heart by following his example.)
My suggestion: Read Psalm 51 and, if that Psalm expresses your true feelings, pray it to the Judge and King of Heaven. He will hear your heart and honor your prayer.
Then lift up your head for your redemption is drawing near!
If this post stirred something in you, I invite you to go deeper. My books and Bible studies at Eagerly Waiting are written for believers who are serious about living faithfully in the time we’ve been given. I’d love to walk this road with you.
Audiobook
Here are links to my blog indexes, so please click one and keep reading!
My Books, Workbooks, and Fun Books
Knowing the Unknowable One
Opening the Treasure Chest
Walking Heart-to-Heart with God
Walking Heart-to-Heart with Each Other
Fighting the Good Fight of Faith
Christian Mysteries: Why I Love Them!
List of Some Nonfiction Books You Don’t Want to Miss
Index of Assorted Topics