It occurred to me one day, reading through a string of familiar verses, that I might be disobeying Scripture every single day without realizing it.
“Rejoice evermore. Pray without ceasing. In every thing give thanks.” (1 Thessalonians 5:16-18) “Rejoice in the Lord always. I will say it again: Rejoice!” (Philippians 4:4) “Giving thanks always for all things.” (Ephesians 5:20) “Let my mouth be filled with thy praise… all the day.” (Psalm 71:8)
Read those together and there’s no wiggle room. Christians aren’t told to figure out how they feel each day and respond honestly. Our feelings are already prescribed: Joyful. Thankful. Praising. Always. In everything.
And then Jesus takes it to an unimaginable degree. He commands joy in persecution. “Blessed are ye, when men shall revile you, and persecute you… Rejoice, and be exceeding glad” (Matthew 5:11-12). Some of the worst suffering on earth right now – Christians imprisoned, beaten, killed for their faith – and Jesus says, “Rejoice.”
The thought that followed was one word: Pollyanna.
Most people don’t mean it kindly when they say it. The glad-game player. The out-of-touch optimist who finds something to be happy about no matter what. I loved the book and the movie growing up, but I know the reputation – naive, childish, a little insufferable.
Except the more I sat with it, the more I realized: based on those verses, Pollyanna might be the only one actually being obedient.
The problem is real, not imagined
Here’s what stops me from trying to walk in eternal cheerfulness: Horrible things happen. Cancer. War. Violence. Death. A friend’s diagnosis. A spouse’s funeral. If someone I love is standing at a graveside, and I walk up radiating the joy of the Lord, that’s not obedience. That’s cruelty wearing a smile.
I don’t think it’s even appropriate for the sufferer herself to express joy in that moment. If I’m the one whose world just fell apart, plastering on gratitude and praise while my heart is in pieces isn’t godliness. It’s denial with a Bible verse taped to it.
So what am I supposed to do with “always,” “continually,” “in every thing”? Keep the joy locked between me and God, like a private conversation no one else is invited to?
Two things happening at once
I think the confusion clears up when we notice Scripture never asks us to choose between joy and grief. It asks for both, running at the same time, aimed in different directions.
Jesus stood outside Lazarus’s tomb knowing He was about to raise him from the dead – full resurrection power, seconds away from undoing the entire tragedy – and He wept anyway (John 11:35). He didn’t skip the grief because He held the outcome. Paul tells the Romans to “rejoice with them that do rejoice, and weep with them that weep” (Romans 12:15). Not one or the other depending on your personal spiritual temperature, but both, given the situation in front of you. Ecclesiastes says there’s “a time to weep, and a time to laugh” (3:4) — not because joy is optional, but because it has a proper shape and timing.
So maybe the “always” and “in every thing” describe something happening underneath – a settled trust and gratitude toward God that never actually shuts off – while the outward expression is governed by something else entirely: love, wisdom, and reading the room.
Notice, too, that Philippians 4:4 doesn’t just say “rejoice always.” It says rejoice in the Lord always. The object of the joy isn’t the circumstance. It’s not “rejoice in the cancer” or “rejoice in the persecution.” It’s rejoicing in Him, in who He is and what He’s doing, even while standing inside something you’d never choose and wouldn’t call good on its own.
That’s the only way I’ve ever been able to actually offer thanksgiving in something dreadful: not by finding a silver lining, Pollyanna-style, but by trusting that God is accomplishing some purpose of His own through it that I can’t yet see. Joseph said it to the brothers who sold him into slavery: “ye thought evil against me; but God meant it unto good” (Genesis 50:20). The evil was still evil. The good was still real. Both, at once.
So what do I do at a deathbed?
Practically, I think this means: I don’t have to manufacture visible gladness to prove I’m being obedient. My continual thanksgiving can be happening quietly before God – I trust You, I don’t understand this, and I still believe You are good – while what I offer the grieving person in front of me is presence, tears, and silence. That’s not a failure to rejoice. That may be exactly what rejoicing “in the Lord” looks like when it’s aimed at loving someone well instead of performing correctly.
And this is where the hope of Christ’s return actually does the heavy lifting. We’re not thankful for evil because we’ve talked ourselves into liking it. We’re thankful in the middle of it because we know how the story ends. “When these things begin to come to pass, then look up, and lift up your heads; for your redemption draweth nigh” (Luke 21:28). The very passage where Jesus describes wars, distress, and fear coming on the earth is the passage where He tells us to look up, not because the suffering isn’t real, but because it isn’t final.
That’s the difference between Pollyanna’s glad game and biblical joy. Pollyanna scrapes the bottom of the barrel, looking for a reason to feel good right now. Christian joy doesn’t need the reason to be found in the present moment at all. It borrows it from the moment “Christ…will appear a second time, not to deal with sin but to save those who are eagerly waiting for him” (Hebrews 9:28). We grieve now, honestly, without pretending. We rejoice always, genuinely, without denial. And we hold both because we’re not living for today’s outcome. We’re living toward His.
***
Audiobook
a
Here are links to my blog indexes, so please click one and keep reading!
My Books, Workbooks, and Fun Books
Knowing the Unknowable One
Opening the Treasure Chest
Walking Heart-to-Heart with God
Walking Heart-to-Heart with Each Other
Fighting the Good Fight of Faith
Christian Mysteries: Why I Love Them!
List of Some Nonfiction Books You Don’t Want to Miss
Index of Assorted Topics